Worst Nursing Homes in Long Island
Long Island is home to seven one-star-rated nursing homes on Medicare’s five-star rating scale, with several additional facilities receiving one-star ratings on staffing, health inspections, or quality measures specifically. Learn more about the worst-rated nursing homes on Long Island to stay informed and keep your loved ones in residential care safe.
- Worst Nursing Homes in Long Island Based on Federal Ratings
- Nursing Homes With an Overall One-Star Rating in Long Island
- One-Star for Health Inspections in Long Island
- One-Star for Staffing in Long Island Nursing Homes
- One-Star for Quality Measures in Long Island
- Lawsuits and Settlements Involving Long Island Nursing Homes
- How To Protect Your Loved Ones in Long Island Nursing Homes
- Contact Nursing Homes Abuse LLC for Help
Choosing a quality nursing home when your loved one is ready for residential care is paramount to their health, safety, and overall wellbeing. In Long Island, numerous nursing homes have received citations or low ratings for quality by federal and state survey agencies. It’s crucial to review these ratings when searching for a nursing facility. If your loved one has experienced neglect or abuse in a Long Island nursing home, we can connect you with a nursing home abuse attorney to advocate for your family.
Worst Nursing Homes in Long Island Based on Federal Ratings
Medicare’s five-star rating system rates nursing homes across the country based on measures like health inspections, staffing, and other quality measures to provide a snapshot of each facility’s quality. Nursing homes with five-star ratings are considered to be above average quality, while nursing homes with one-star ratings are considered to be below average quality. Additionally, Medicare marks some nursing homes with a symbol if they have been cited for abuse or neglect.
Nursing Homes With an Overall One-Star Rating in Long Island
Medicare’s star-rating system works to inform the public of the general quality of nursing homes based on measures of patient care, safety, quality, staffing, and more. A one-star rating denotes a facility that is much below average in health inspections, staffing, and quality measures. It’s crucial to investigate facilities with low ratings before making decisions about long term care.
In Long Island, there are seven nursing homes with an overall one-star rating as of early 2026, including three that have been cited for potential nursing home abuse:
- Woodbury Heigths Nursing and Rehabilitation Center
- Medford Multicare Center for Living
- A. Holly Patterson Extended Care Facility (cited for potential abuse)
- Hempstead Park Nursing Home (cited for potential abuse)
- Mayfair Care Center
- The Hamptons Center for Rehabilitation and Nursing (cited for potential abuse)
- San Simeon by the Sound Center for Nursing & Rehab
One-Star for Health Inspections in Long Island
Under state and federal laws and regulations, nursing homes must meet standards to protect residents by hiring enough quality staff to provide adequate care, managing medications properly, protecting residents from abuse, and more. In Long Island, state survey agencies conduct nursing home health inspections at least once a year. The inspection team looks at resident care, how staff interacts with residents, and the nursing home environment. Facilities with low health inspection ratings frequently receive citations and cause real harm to residents. As of early 2026, Long Island has five nursing homes with one-star health inspection ratings:
- Woodbury Heights Nursing and Rehabilitation Center
- Medford Multicare Center for Living
- A. Holly Patterson Extended Care Facility
- The Hamptons Center for Rehabilitation and Nursing
- San Simeon by the Sound Center for Nursing & Rehab
One-Star for Staffing in Long Island Nursing Homes
Staffing star ratings are based on how many Registered Nurse hours per day each resident receives, staffing hours per resident per day, nursing staff turnover rates, administrative turnover rates, and more staffing data points. Understaffing a nursing home can easily lead to resident neglect as staff become overwhelmed by requests for assistance. As of early 2026, two nursing homes on Long Island have a staffing rating of one star:
- Medford Multicare Center for Living
- Hempstead Park Nursing Home
One-Star for Quality Measures in Long Island
The quality measures star rating by Medicare measures nursing home performance in certain areas of care, like if residents have been properly vaccinated, are in pain, or are losing weight. If these measures show that resident well-being is low, the star rating decreases. The rating is calculated from both short- and long-stay resident quality measures. As of early 2026, only one nursing home in Long Island has a quality measures rating of 1 star: the Mayfair Care Center.
Get Legal Help
At Nursing Homes Abuse LLC, we partner with experienced nursing home abuse attorneys who can assist you and your loved ones to get the justice you deserve.
Mathew Shooshtary
The Sanders Law Firm
Jay Kenneth Margolis
The Sanders Law Firm
Lawsuits and Settlements Involving Long Island Nursing Homes
Medford Multicare Center for Living ($28 Million Settlement)
In June 2016, a Long Island nursing home reached a $28 million settlement regarding a 72-year-old patient’s death in 2012. Medford Multicare Center was sued for alleged fraud and illegal operations, and was ordered to return over $10 million to Medicaid as restitution in addition to the settlement. Executives faced criminal consequences for attempting to cover up the circumstances of the death, which was ruled to be the result of neglect.
Cold Spring Hills Center for Nursing and Rehabilitation
In December 2022, the New York Attorney General sued Cold Spring Hills Center for Nursing and Rehabilitation in Nassau County for financial fraud that led to severe understaffing and resident neglect and harm. An investigation found that the center’s owners diverted nearly $23 million in Medicare and Medicaid funds from resident care for profit.
Fulton Commons Care Center ($8.6 Million Settlement)
In March 2024, the New York Attorney General secured a settlement with Fulton Commons Care Center, Inc. for $8.6 million after an investigation revealed longstanding resident neglect, abuse, and financial fraud. The owners and operators were ordered to pay up to $7 million to implement numerous reforms for resident safety and to pay an additional $1.6 million in restitution to Medicare and Medicaid for illegally diverting funds.
How To Protect Your Loved Ones in Long Island Nursing Homes
Recognizing Signs of Neglect and Abuse
Some of the most common signs of neglect and abuse in nursing homes include unexplained injuries, sudden weight loss, poor hygiene, and emotional withdrawal.
Steps To Take If You Suspect Neglect
Nursing home abuse and neglect are forms of medical malpractice. Patients have a right to expect to receive a reasonable standard of care while residing in nursing homes, and facilities that fail to meet these standards are liable.
If you believe your loved one is in immediate danger or needs urgent medical attention in a Long Island nursing home, call 911. You can also report your concerns to the New York State Department of Health by calling 1-888-201-4563 or completing the online Nursing Home Complaint Form. Keep detailed records of any suspected abuse and subsequent medical care.
It’s also important to engage a Long Island nursing home abuse attorney as soon as possible to ensure your loved one is safe and their rights are protected. An attorney can help you determine the best legal path forward for your family and help you file a nursing home abuse or neglect lawsuit.
Contact Nursing Homes Abuse LLC for Help
If you suspect your loved one was a victim of neglect or abuse in a Long Island nursing home, Nursing Homes Abuse LLC can help. We work to inform families of the risks of nursing home abuse and provide legal aid if a resident has been injured. We can help you find the best legal support for the abuse or neglect your loved one endured. Contact us today for a free legal consultation to learn more about your legal rights and options.
